Simulation of a Campus Backbone Network, a case-study
J. Potemans1, J. Theunis, B. Rodiers, B. Van den Broeck, P. Leys, E. Van Lil, A. Van de Capelle
Katholieke Universiteit Leuven (K.U.Leuven)
Department of Electrical Engineering
ESAT-TELEMIC division
Kasteelpark Arenberg 10
B-3001 Heverlee (Leuven), Belgium
E-mail: jan.potemans@esat.kuleuven.ac.be
Abstract Section 3 gives an overview of the traffic measurements on these
This paper describes the work performed in the framework of a networks together with the problems encountered. The OPNET
Master s thesis. The aim of the thesis was to make a simulation model of these networks is dealt with in section 4. The
model in OPNET Modeler of the backbone at the K.U.Leuven, integration of the measured data into the OPNET topology is
Belgium. The backbone consists of five Cisco Catalyst 5500 discussed in detail. Section 5 describes how this model can be
switches in a ring topology interconnected by full-duplex fine-tuned. A VoIP case study is worked out in section 6.
Gigabit Ethernet links. Accurate real-life measurements are used Finally, section 7 sums up the conclusions of this paper.
to add background traffic to this topology. The use of VLANs to
separate traffic generated by students and personnel adds extra 2. Topology
difficulties (the traffic is routed at different locations). This The backbone network consists of five Cisco Catalyst 5500
paper gives an overview of the results and the problems backbone switches, interconnected by a full-duplex Gigabit
encountered. Ethernet ring. Figure 1 gives an overview of this ring topology
with the five backbone switches: laswitch-ludit, laswitch-cw,
1. Introduction laswitch-straf, laswitch-hh and laswitch-esat (according to their
Computer networks have become extremely important in our location). All these backbone switches have routing capabilities.
present-day society. A majority of companies depend on the
proper functioning of their networks for communications,
laswitch-hh
laswitch-hh
administration, automation, e-business solutions etc. Outage of
the network can cost a company millions of euros.
To avoid these problems, system managers need professional
tools to help them with the design and maintenance of computer
networks. A simulation tool offers a way to predict the impact
on the network of a hardware upgrade, a change in topology, an
laswitch-esat
laswitch-esat
laswitch-straf
laswitch-straf
increase in traffic load or the use of a new application. OPNET
Technologies offers a number of tools specifically designed for
these purposes.
This paper describes how the Modeler tool can be used to make
laswitch-cw laswitch-ludit
laswitch-cw laswitch-ludit
a simulation model for the campus backbone network of the
K.U.Leuven, Belgium. It is a summary of the work performed in
FigureFigure 2: Bluetooth OPNET Node Model
Figure 1: Backbone topology
the framework of a Master s thesis [1].
It is clear that this thesis was not proposed in the perspective Several peripheral switches are attached to these backbone
described above. Our university won t loose that much money switches to offer connectivity to local sites, which can be
when the network is down. The aim of the thesis is rather a study administrative services, research groups, auditoria, classrooms,
of the possibilities, problems and limitations of today s student dorms etc. Figure 2 shows how the Local Area Networks
simulation tools. This study fits into the doctoral research on
(LANs) are linked to the backbone.
hybrid simulation techniques performed in our group. ESAT-
Telemic is a partner in OPNET s University Program and uses
Virtual LANs (VLANs) [8] are used to define logical units to
the Modeler simulation tool both for research [2,3,4] and which people of the same administrative service, research group,
education [5,6,7]. etc. belong. This makes it possible for users of the same unit to
connect to the network from geographically distributed locations
This paper is organized as follows: the topology of both the
(which is important because the university buildings are spread
backbone network and the Internet access network of the
over town).
university is discussed in section 2.
1
Research Assistant of the Fund of Scientific Research Flanders (FWO-Vlaanderen)
1
Webcache cluster
Webcache cluster
backbone
backbone
peripheral switch
peripheral switch
Kotnet routers
Kotnet routers
Firewall cluster
Firewall cluster
backbone switch
backbone switch
Internet
Internet
LAN 1 LAN 2 LAN 3
LAN 1 LAN 2 LAN 3
Cisco-kulnet
Cisco-kulnet
Cisco-access
Cisco-access
Figure 2: Local sites connected to the
backbone via peripheral switches
KULeuvenNet
KULeuvenNet
NAT cluster
NAT cluster
A clear distinction is made between units of university personnel
and units of students. Student VLANs (auditoria, classrooms,
university student dorms) are trunked over the backbone and
Figure 4: Internet access network for KotNet
centrally routed by the Kotnet routers. Personnel VLANs can
also be routed by the router modules in the backbone switches.
3. Measurements
Most of the peripheral switches are connected to two backbone The performance of a network heavily depends on the amount of
switches (or to each other) to introduce redundancy in the traffic occupying the links and the queues (in routers and
system. The Spanning Tree Protocol (STP) is used to obtain a switches) throughout the network. To get a clear understanding
loop free topology: all redundant links are put in standby. The of the traffic load on the backbone network, accurate
STP protocol is executed per VLAN. measurements are needed. The Simple Network Management
Protocol (SNMP) [9,10] can be used to get information stored in
The distinction between students and personnel also becomes switches and routers. The Management Information Base (MIB)
clear in the access network to the Internet. Figure 3 depicts this [11] specifies which data is stored in the network equipment. In
access network for the KULeuvenNet, the network for university this project the counters for the incoming and outgoing traffic
personnel. Connection to the Internet is made through two per interface both in packets and bytes are queried using the
routers: Cisco-Access and Cisco-Kulnet. Both are Cisco 7206 free snmpget tool [12].
routers. A firewall in between protects the network against
unauthorized access. A web caching system is provided to The scripting language Perl is used to automate the
relieve the connection to the Internet. measurements. A first set of scripts queries every two minutes
all the interfaces of every router and switch of the backbone and
Webcache cluster the Internet access network. Four counter values per interface are
Webcache cluster
saved in a text file: the number of incoming packets, the number
of incoming bytes, the number of outgoing packets and the
number of outgoing bytes. A second set of scripts processes the
Cisco-kulnet
Cisco-kulnet
saved data. For each interval of two minutes, the average
number of incoming and outgoing packets and bits per second is
calculated.
Internet
Internet
Cisco-access
Cisco-access
The major problem is that one could only measure the amount of
traffic that entered or exited via a particular interface (the
KULeuvenNet
KULeuvenNet
software installed on the backbone switches did not allow to
Firewall cluster
Firewall cluster
measure inter-VLAN traffic). In most cases it is not clear how
the incoming traffic is distributed over the outgoing interfaces.
Figure 3: Internet access for KULeuvenNet
Figure 5 shows a backbone switch with five interfaces. It is
possible to measure the data streams 1 to 10. Assuming that
Figure 4 shows the access network to the Internet for Kotnet, the most of the traffic comes from or goes to the backbone, this
student network of the university. Instead of the Kulnet router, picture can be simplified as in Figure 6 with only four data
three Kotnet routers are used. Kotnet-1 is used for routing traffic streams. The traffic between two backbone switches is simulated
to and from two cable operators (offering access in private using point-to-point traffic between two stations connected to
dorms). Kotnet-2 serves all the student dorms of the university. these switches.
These are Cisco 7507 routers. Next to routing they also need to
control access and collect network usage statistics for every There is however a difference between both pictures. In Figure 5
single student, which explains the choice for very powerful streams 1 and 4 enter the switch, while streams 2 and 3 exit the
routers. Kotnet-3, a Cisco 4700 router, is used for dialin, switch. In Figure 6 all four streams enter (and exit) the switch. If
auditoria and PC classrooms. A Network Address Translation no traffic leaves the backbone (1 = 3 and 2 = 4) the switch in
(NAT) cluster is used because students are assigned private IP- Figure 6 is loaded twice as much. However if all traffic leaves
addresses (by a DHCP server). the backbone, the switch will be loaded correctly.
2
In reality the load will be somewhere between these two Only for the webcaching infrastructure no appropriate model
extremes. Therefore fine-tuning of the model will be necessary could be found in the library. Instead of using the available
(see section 5). cache-server, a workstation is used in combination with a basic
switching device (without specialized features like VLANs).
This way all the kotnet routers, the kulnet router and the access
router could use the webcaching device. Measurements show
that a byte-hit ratio of 26% is attained.
1
1
3
3
4
4
2
2
5 10
5 10
6
6
9
9
7 8
7 8
Figure 5: Measured traffic streams in a backbone switch
1
1
3
3
4
4
2
2
Figure 7: OPNET topology for the backbone network
To add traffic to these topologies, pairs of workstations are
connected to the backbone switches: e.g. workstations esat-hh
and hh-esat, connected to laswitch-esat and laswitch-hh
respectively are used to add traffic on the backbone link between
these two switches.
Figure 6: Corresponding data streams in OPNET
There is one case in which the routing is known. Kotnet traffic
(caused by students) is trunked over the backbone to one of the
Kotnet routers (and vice-versa). The easiest way to measure the
amount of traffic to and from each student site (a student house,
an auditorium, & ) is by querying these Kotnet-routers.
Measuring on the peripheral switches, to which the sites are
directly connected, is much more difficult because internal
traffic of the site is also visible (and accounted for) on the
respective interface of the switch.
4. OPNET model
Figure 7 shows the OPNET topology of the backbone in case the
Kotnet traffic is subtracted from the other traffic and dealt with
separately. By giving this traffic a VLAN identifier it is trunked
over the backbone and routed in the Kotnet routers.
Figure 8: OPNET topology for Internet access
Figure 8 depicts the Internet access network topology, in which
the icon KULeuvenNet represents the topology of Figure 7.
Analogously workstation esat-kotnet1 exchanges traffic with a
Every node comes directly from the component library or is
workstation attached to the kotnet-1 router. The webcache
generated using the device creator (to have the appropriate
workstation is used to represent the traffic coming from and
number and type of interfaces). For the routers and switches the
going to the webcache device.
packet-forwarding rate, the memory size and the capacity of the
backplane can be adjusted.
3
The measured traffic is integrated in the topology as background It was impossible to treat the Kotnet traffic separately. The
traffic to enable hybrid simulations. This type of simulations is topology of Figure 7 is simplified to the topology of Figure 11 in
far more efficient than discrete event simulations because only which the Kotnet traffic is added to the remaining workstation
explicit traffic needs to be simulated. The queuing behavior of pairs. The trunking behavior is lost which makes the model far
this traffic is based on the background traffic load on the queues less accurate (even after fine-tuning).
throughout the topology. Background traffic can be inserted
using the conversation pair browser (see Figure 9).
Figure 9: Conversation pair browser
For each couple of workstations one can configure the
appropriate background traffic profile. These profiles were
Figure 11: Backbone topology without separate
imported from a text file, composed by a Perl script that
KotNet traffic
transforms the measured data into the correct format. This
format was obtained by exporting an empty conversation pair
matrix to a text file. Figure 10 shows the imported traffic on the
Another problem encountered concerns the Spanning Tree
backbone link from ludit to esat.
protocol. OPNET doesn t support the Per VLAN Spanning Tree
(PVST) protocol yet. This means that always one link of the
Gigabit Ethernet ring remains unloaded whereas in reality, there
is traffic on every link. To prevent a heavily used link from
being put in standby, we marked the least used link as failed (see
Figure 11).
Analysis of the measured data also showed that the backbone
traffic was self-similar [13]. This means that the traffic is much
more bursty than in traditional models like Poisson. The
background traffic configuration did not support self-similar
packet arrival. The Raw Packet Generator (RPG) [3] model,
which can be used to generate self-similar traffic, only works for
explicit traffic. Due to the division of the traffic in small
intervals of 2 minutes, a Poisson approximation (exponential
interarrival time variability) seems reasonable.
The packet size variability should also be specified in the
background traffic configuration utility. A packet size
probability distribution function could not be extracted out of the
SNMP measurements. By dividing the number of bytes/sec by
the number of packets/sec, one can only calculate the average
Figure 10: Imported traffic from ludit to esat
packet size in a time interval. When averaging out over the
complete time range, a single (needed by OPNET) mean packet
size is obtained which is entered in the configuration box
The measured data could be easily inserted in the model, except
together with a constant distribution as approximation.
for the Kotnet traffic. The specific trunking behavior (caused by
the use of a VLAN) was not supported in background.
4
5. Fine-tuning of the model The predefined IP Telephony application is used to configure the
Due to the unknown routing behavior of the traffic (explained in calling profiles. The ITU G.729 standard with Voice Activity
section 3), the load of the routers and the switches in the Detection is used as codec. The distribution of the call duration
topology is no longer correct. This problem was compensated together with the average number of calls per second are derived
for by adjusting the packet-forwarding rate of these devices. from call records during a peak hour. These numbers are used to
Note that this scaling is only an approximation. adjust the application and profile settings. It is important to
mention that the number of VoIP users is taken arbitrarily but
During one day of measurements, the round trip times (RTT) of that the profiles are adjusted to generate the total number of calls
some ping (ICMP) packets were determined every hour. These measured.
packets originated from a workstation connected to laswitch-esat
and had one of the other switches or routers as destination.
The fine-tuning of the model consisted of simulating the same
ping application in OPNET and adjusting the packet-forwarding
rates of the switches and routers until the round trip times
matched reality. This procedure was performed for each node
separately. Figure 12 shows how ping packets are sent from esat
to a ping-server at cw.
Figure 13: Voice users added to the topology
The quality of a VoIP call depends on the end-to-end delay, the
jitter and the packet loss. Simulations show that the average
(after an initialisation period) network delay for the VoIP
packets is only 0.474 milliseconds which can be neglected. Also
the jitter is very limited and there is even no packet loss. One
can conclude that the integration of voice traffic will cause no
problems for the backbone network. If problems are encountered
they will most probably originate from the access network.
7. Conclusion
This paper showed how the OPNET Modeler tool can be used
for the simulation of a backbone network. The Campus
Figure 12: A ping-server connected at cw
backbone network of the K.U.Leuven, Belgium, served as a
case-study for this paper.
OPNET has no built-in ICMP application. However, a custom
application was built very quickly. It turned out that not all information necessary could be
measured by the software on the switches and routers. This lack
6. Case-study: Voice over IP of information (about routing behavior) strongly compromises
To illustrate the benefits of the designed simulation model, a the accuracy of the simulation model.
more detailed case-study was performed. The aim is to
determine whether the backbone infrastructure is powerful Furthermore, the Modeler software did not allow to include all
enough to integrate the phone traffic with the current data traffic features present in the backbone network. It was impossible to
[14, 15]. allocate VLANs and self-similar behavior to background traffic.
The Per VLAN Spanning Tree protocol was not supported.
Figure 13 shows the modified topology for the integration of
voice traffic. A LAN representing VoIP users, is connected to However, if all these problems were to be overcome, the OPNET
each backbone switch. A gateway to the PSTN is represented by Modeler simulation environment would offer a very useful tool
a switch and connected to the backbone switch at ludit. The for the design and management of our backbone network.
voice_extern LAN represents people calling to the university
while the voice-extern server is used as destination for outgoing
calls.
5
References
[1] B. Rodiers, Analysis & Simulation of the K.U.Leuven-network (in
Dutch), thesis to obtain the degree of Master in Electronics Engineering,
K.U.Leuven, Belgium, June 2002.
[2] B. Van den Broeck, P. Leys, J. Potemans, J. Theunis, E. Van Lil and
A. Van de Capelle, Validation of router models in OPNET ,
OPNETWORK 2002, Washington D.C., USA, August 2002.
[3] P. Leys, J. Potemans, B. Van den Broeck, J. Theunis, E. Van Lil and
A. Van de Capelle, Use of the Raw Packet Generator in OPNET ,
OPNETWORK 2002, Washington D.C., USA, August 2002.
[4] M. Teughels, E. Van Lil, and A. Van de Capelle, "Backbone
Network Simulation: a Self-Similar Perpetuum Mobile",
OPNETWORK 1999, Washington D.C., USA, August 1999.
[5] J. Theunis, B. Van den Broeck, P. Leys, J. Potemans, E. Van Lil and
A. Van de Capelle, OPNET in Advanced Networking Education ,
OPNETWORK 2002, Washington D.C., USA, August 2002.
[6] J. Potemans, J. Theunis, M. Teughels, E. Van Lil and A. Van de
Capelle, Student Network Design Projects using OPNET ,
OPNETWORK 2001, Washington D.C., USA, August 2001.
[7] J. Theunis, J. Potemans, M. Teughels, A. Van de Capelle and E. Van
Lil, Project Driven Graduate Network Education , Proc. to the
International Conference on Networking ICN 01, Colmar, France,
pp.790-802, 2001.
[8] S. McQuerry, Interconnecting Cisco Network Devices (Chapter 6:
Extending Switched Networks with Virtual LANs), Cisco Press, 2000.
[9] J.D. Case, M. Fedor, M.L. Schoffstall, C. Davin, Simple Network
Management Protocol (SNMP) , RFC 1157, May 1990.
[10] J. Case, K. McCloghrie, M. Rose, S. Waldbusser, Introduction to
version 2 of the Internet-standard Network Management Framework ,
RFC 1441, April 1993.
[11] K. McCoghrie, D. Perkins, J. Schoenwaelder, Structure of
Management Information Version 2 (SMIv2) , RFC 2578, April 1990.
[12] NET-SNMP home page: http://net-snmp.sourceforge.net
[13] W. Leland, M. Taqqu, W. Willinger, D. Wilson, On the Self-
Similar Nature of Ethernet Traffic (Extended Version) , IEEE/ACM
Transactions on Networking, vol.2, no.1, pp. 1-15, February 1994.
[14] J. Bankston et al., Cisco AVVID and IP Telephony Design and
Implementation , Sygress Publishing, 2001.
[15] R. Caputo, Cisco Packetized Voice & Data Integration ,
McGraw-Hill Professional Publishing, 1999.
6
Wyszukiwarka
Podobne podstrony:
Case Study of Industrial Espionage Through Social EngineeringViral Blog Post Case Studycase study pracujplCase study 1 za??znik 5Case study 1 za??znik 1Youtube Bully 2 Case StudySimulation of the Erosion Burning of a Granular PropellantSimulation of Convective Detonation Waves in a Porous Medium by the Lattice Gas MethodC uwiczenia MwAS case study 1DudeIHateMyJob com Dude I Hate My Job Case Study (pdf)Case study 1 za??znik 3Simulation of vapour explosionsCase study 1 za??znik 6Simulation of the Behavior of Mixtures of Heavy Particles Behind a Shock Wave Frontcase studyCase study Elektroskandiawięcej podobnych podstron