CONSTRUCTING
GENOGRAMS
Genograms are part of the more general process of family assess-
ment. In this chapter we will describe how to both construct a geno-
gram and elicit relevant genogram information from a family during
assessment.
CREATING A GENOGRAM
Creating a genogram involves three levels: 1) mapping the family
structure, 2) recording family information, and 3) delineating family
relationships.
Mapping the Family Structure
The backbone of a genogram is a graphic depiction of how dif-
ferent family members are biologically and legally related to one an-
other from one generation to the next. This map is a construction
of figures representing people and lines delineating their relation-
ships. As with any map, the representation will have meaning only
if the symbols are defined for those who are trying to read the geno-
gram. Not surprisingly, there is a great deal of diversity in the way
clinicians draw genograms. Different groups have their own favorite
symbols and ways of dealing with complicated family constellations,
which often leads to confusion in reading other clinicians' genograms.
Recently a group of family physicians and family therapists (aTask
Force of the North American Primary Care Research Group),chaired
by has collaborated to standardize the symbols and
Genograms in Family Assessment
Male Female
Diagram 2.1 Gender symbols
Male I. F? Female I.
Diagram 2.2 Index person symbols
Birthdate Deathdate
Diagram 2.3 Birthdates and deathdates
cedures for drawing the genogram. These procedures form the basis
for the guidelines presented here.
The family structure shows different family members in relation
to one another. Each family member is represented by a box or circle
according to his or her gender (Diagram 2.1). For the index person
(or identified patient) around whom the genogram is constructed,
the lines are doubled (Diagram 2.2). For a person who is dead, an
X is placed inside the figure. Birth and death dates are indicated
to the left and right above the figure (Diagram 2.3). The person's
age at death is usually indicated within the figure. For example
the male depicted here was born in 1943 and died in 1962 at the
age of 19. In extended genograms that go back more than three
generations, figures in the distant past are not usually crossed out,
since they are presumably dead. Only relevant deaths are indicated
in such genograms.
Constructing Genograms 11
Pregnancies, miscarriages, abortions and stillbirths are indicated
by other symbols (Diagram 2.4).
pregnancy stillbirth or spontaneous induced
1
abortion abortion
A
Diagram 2.4 Symbols for pregnancy, miscarrage, abortion and stillbirth
The figures representing family members are connected by lines
that indicate their biological and legal relationships.
Two people who are married are connected by lines that go down
and across, with the husband on the left and the wife on the right
(Diagram 2.5). followed by a date indicates when the couple was
married. Sometimes only the last two digits of the year are shown
m.48) when there is little chance of confusion regarding the
appropriate century. The marriage line is also the place where separa-
tions or divorces are indicated (Diagram 2.6). The slashes signify
a disruption in the marriage-one slash for separation and two for
a divorce.
Diagram 2.5 Marriage connections
Diagram 2.6 Separations and divorces
in Family Assessment
Diagram 2.7 A husband with several wives
Diagram 2.8 A wife with several husbands
Multiple marriages add a degree of complexity that is sometimes
difficult to depict. Diagram 2.7 shows one way of indicating several
wives of one husband while Diagram 2.8 shows several husbands
l
of one wife. The rule of thumb is that, when feasible, the different
marriages follow in order from left to right, with the most recent
marriage coming last. The marriage and divorce dates should also
help to make the order clear. However, when each spouse has had
multiple partners (and possibly children from previous
mapping out the complex web of relationships can be very difficult
indeed. One solution is to place the most recent relationship in the
center and each partner's former spouses off to the as in Dia-
gram 2.9.
Diagram 2.9 Two partners who have each had multiple spouses
Constructing Genograms 13
Diagram 2.10 Remarriages where each spouse has had several other partners
If previous spouses have had other partners, it may be necessary
to draw a second line, slightly above the first marriage line, to in-
dicate these relationships. In Diagram 2.10 each spouse has been
married twice before. The husband's former wife had been married
once before she married him, and she remarried afterwards. The
wife's second husband has remarried since their divorce.
Diagram 2.11 Unmarried couple
If a couple are involved in a love affair or living together but not
legally married, their relationship is depicted as with married cou-
ples, but a dotted line is used (Diagram 2.11). The important date
here is when they met or started living together. (This may also be
important information for married couples.)
Diagram 2.12 Birth order
If a couple has children, then each child's figure hangs down from
the line that connects the couple. Children are drawn left to right
going from the oldest to the youngest, as in Diagram 2.12. If there
Diagram 2.13 Alternative method for depicting family with many children
are many children in a family, an alternate method (Diagram 2.13)
may be used to save space. A dotted line is used to connect a foster
or adopted child to the parents' line (Diagram 2.14). And finally, con-
verging lines connect twins to the parental line. If the twins are iden-
tical, a bar connects them to each other (Diagram 2.15).
Diagram 2.14 Foster or adopted children
Diagram 2.15 Twins
Diagram 2.16 Households of remarried families
Dotted lines are used to encircle the family members living in the
immediate household. This is especially important in remarried fam-
ilies where children spend time in various households, as in the
gram shown in Diagram 2.16.
Now that we have the basic symbols and procedures for mapping
the family structure on a let us put them into practice
by using the family of a well-known celebrity of the psychiatric
world: Sigmund Freud. Neither Freud nor his biographers ever did
extensive research into his family and the details of his family life
are sketchy. Nevertheless, we do know the basic structure of the
Freud family.
First, we draw Sigmund's marriage to Martha and their children
(Diagram 2.17).
1861-1951
Martha
1889-1967 1892-1970 1895-1982
Mathilde Martin Oliver Ernest Sophie Anna
Diagram 2.17 Freud nuclear family
Next, we go back a generation and include both Sigmund's and
Martha's parents and siblings (Diagram 2.18). In fact, we usually
go back to the grandparents of the index person, including at least
three generations on the genogram (four or even five generations
if the index person has children and grandchildren).
1856
0
Schlomo Pepi Jacob Sara
Nathanson
Hoffman
Joseph
Q
Jakob Sally Rebecca Amalia Emmehne
Kanner Nathanson Bernays
Julius
0
Eli Minna
0
Martha
m 86
Martin Anna never married
Fuchs
Diagram 2.18 Freud family -five generations
To highlight their central importance, the figures for Sigmund and
Martha are lowered out of the sibling line. As can also be seen on
this diagram, the spouses of siblings are also usually placed slight-
ly lower than the siblings themselves, to keep the sibling
clear.
After the family structure has been drawn, the members of
household are encircled. Diagram 2.19 shows the Freud household
in 1896, the year after their last child, Anna, was born, and the year
that Sigmund's sister-in-law came to live with them.
1835- -1879
1815-96
El 66)
0
Arnalia
Sally Rebecca
Jakob
Kanner Bernays
1855-72
1857-57
1833-
Anna Eli
1868-
,
Minna
1856-
Mathilde Martin Oliver Ernest Sophie Anna
\
Diagram 2.19 Freud immediate household
The date in the bottom righthand corner tells the year when this
genogram snapshot was taken. A clinician might use the genogram
to freezeframe a moment in the past, such as the time of symptom
onset or critical change in a family. When we choose one date in a
person's life, other information, deaths, ages and important events
are calculated in relation to that set date. It is then useful to put
each person's age inside his or her figure. If the person is dead, the
age at death is used instead. In Diagram 2.20, for example, we have
somewhat arbitrarily chosen 1900, the year when Freud's first major
book, The Interpretation of Dreams, was published. At that date
there had been only a few deaths in the family Sigmund's father,
his brother Julius, and Martha's brother Isaac.
-1856
Q
Q
Jamb Sara
Pepi
Hoffman
----
housewife
Vienna
Q
tuberculosis merchant
Jakob merchant Sally Rebecca
Kanner
m 55
m.32 m 51?
I
1833-
textiles
dealer
Minna
Philip migrated
after
118591
1860-Jakob moved
family to Vienna
1895-Anna Freud was
MD -began
1896-Minna. Freud's Vienna
wife's sister, had
moved in
Sigmund
1896-Freud's father.
Jakob, died.
1900-Interpretation
published.
Mathilde Martin Oliver Ernest Sophie Anna
Diagram 2.20 Freud family with demographic, functioning, and critical event information.
When only partial information can be unearthed, that is included.
For instance, Sigmund's father was married three times. We know
that he had two children with his first wife, but little is known about
his second wife, Rebecca (Clark,1980; Glicklhorn, 1969). The third
wife, of course, was Sigmund's mother, Amalia Nathanson.
Freud's is a relatively simple family to map. Unfortunately, not
all families are so easy to show in simple graphic form. The numerous
divorces and remarriages of many modern families and their com-
plex biological and legal family relationships make drawing family
structures a challenge. Later in this chapter we will discuss more
complex family structures.
Recording Family Information
Once we have drawn the family structure, the skeleton of the
gram, we can start adding information about the family, particularly:
a) demographic information; b) functioning information; and c) crit-
ical family events.
Demographic information includes ages, dates of birth and death,
locations, occupations, and educational level.
Functional information includes more or less objective data on
the medical, emotional and behavioral functioning of different family
members. Objective signs, such as absenteeism from work and drink-
ing patterns, may be more useful indications of a person's function-
ing than vague reports of problems by family members. Signs of
highly successful functioning should also be included. The informa-
tion collected on each person is placed next to his or her symbol on
the genogram.
Critical family events include important transitions, relationship
shifts, migrations, losses and successes. These give a sense of the
historical continuity of the family and of the effect of the family
history on each individual. Some of these events will have been noted
as demographic data, family births and deaths. Others include
marriages, separations, divorces, moves and job changes. Critical
life events are recorded either in the margin of the genogram or, if
necessary, on a separate attached page.
We generally keep a family chronology with the genogram. This
is a listing in order of occurrence of important events in the family
history that may have affected the individual. At times we make
a special chronology for a critical time period, for example, to track
a family member's illness in relation to other significant events. An
individual chronology may also be useful for tracking a particular
family member's life course (symptoms, functioning) within the con-
text of the family.
Both the year and a brief description of each occurrence should
be listed. For example, the following short list of critical events
might appear on the Freud genogram:
1860 Jakob moved family to Vienna.
1895 Anna Freud was born (last child).
1896 Minna, Sigmund's wife's sister, moved in.
1896 Sigmund's father, Jakob, died.
1900 Interpretation of Dreams published.
When family members are unsure about dates, approximate dates
should be given, preceded by a question mark, ?84 or
A more extensive chronology of family events could then be placed
on a separate sheet of paper:
1855 Jakob Freud and Nathanson marry.
2/21/1856 Salamon Freud (Jakob's father) dies.
5/6/1856 Sigmund Freud is born in Freiberg.
411857 Julius Freud is born.
1211857 Julius Freud dies.
1858 Anna Freud (Sigmund's sister) is born.
1860 Jakob moves his whole family to Vienna.
1866 Sigmund enters gymnasium (age 10).
1866 Alexander Freud is born (last child).
1873 Sigmund begins medical studies (age 17).
1879 Sigmund serves in military for 1 year.
1881 Sigmund receives medical degree (age 24).
1882 Sigmund becomes engaged to Martha Bernays.
1884 Sigmund publishes paper on cocaine.
1885 Sigmund attends lectures in Paris.
1886 Sigmund and Martha marry.
1889 Jean Martin Freud is born (first child).
1894 Sigmund's self-analysis begins.
1895 Anna Freud is born (last child).
1895 Sigmund publishes Studies on Hysteria.
1896 Minna, Sigmund's wife's sister, moves in.
1896 dies.
1900 Sigmund publishes Interpretation of Dreams.
Sigmund ends self-analysis.
1902 Sigmund becomes Extraordinary Professor.
Clearly, a family chronology can vary in length and detail dependin
g
on the breadth and depth of the information available.
Let us look again at the Freud family genogram, with informa-
tion on demographics, functioning, and critical events (Diagram 2.20,
p. 18).
Showing Family Relationships
The third level of genogram construction is the most inferen-
tial. This involves delineating the relationships between family mem-
bers. Such characterizations are based on the report of family mem-
bers and direct observations. Different lines are used to symbolize
the various types of relationship between two family members (Dia-
gram 2.21). Although such commonly used relationship descriptors
as "fused or "conflictual" are difficult to define operationally and
have different connotations for clinicians with various perspectives,
these symbols are useful in clinical practice. Since relationship pat-
terns can be quite complex, it is often useful to represent them on
a separate genogram.
Very close or fused
Fused and conflictual
Poor or conflictual
Close
......................................
----it---
Distant
Estranged or cut-off
Diagram 2.21 Relationship lines
Again, the Freud family will be used to illustrate. Speculating
the relationship patterns of historical figures a chancy business.
Without trying to justify our speculations, the in Diagram
2.22 presents some of the possible relationship patterns that the
available family background information on Freud suggests to us.
Mathilde Martin Oliver Ernest Sophie Anna
Diagram 2.22 Freud family -relationship patterns
COMPLEX GENOGRAMS
Genograms can become very complex and there is no set of rules
that will cover all contingencies. We will show some of the ways we
have dealt with a few common problems.
First, how do you plan ahead? Obviously, if you fill three-fourths
of the page with father's three siblings, you will be stuck when you
get to the mother and find she is the youngest of 12. It helps to get
an overview of the number of siblings and marriages in the
tal generation before starting. The following questions will help
plan and thus anticipate complexities from the start:
How many times was each parent married?
How many siblings did each parent have and where was he or
in the birth order?
For example, if you mapped the structure of Jane fami-
ly of origin, the basic framework would look like Diagram 2.23. The
genogram shows Jane's parents and grandparents. Each of her par-
ents had had previous marriages and her father, Henry, had subse-
quent marriages. The other marriages are shown to the side of each
parent and are dated to indicate the order.
Henry Sibling Position Unknown
Fonda
rn.31-s.32
m.60
1940-
Pan
Jane
Diagram 2.23 Fonda family -basic structure
Generally, the focal point of the genogram is the index person and
details about others in the genogram are shown as they relate to this
person. The complexity of the genogram will thus depend on the
depth and breadth of the information included. For example, if we
were to include Jane's nuclear family, more detail on her mother's,
father's, and sibling's various marriages, as well as the patterns of
suicides, psychiatric hospitalizations and traumatic events, the
gram would look something like Diagram 2.24.
lived with 1949-50
Booth
.
car
suicide suicide
4/50: only Henry and Sophie
attended Frances' funeral.
Children not told of suicide
U
Henry went on stage that
Friends of Henry
night
11/61: Family house in
California burned with
many memorabilia
Diagram 2.24 Fonda family with details
This complex and crowded genogram reveals such important de-
tails as:
Multiple marriages are common in this family.
Both of Henry Fonda's first two wives committed suicide.
Henry Fonda separated from his second wife, Jane's mother,
a few months before she committed suicide. He had already
an affair with his third wife, Susan whom he married
eight months later.
At the time of the third marriage (in fact, during the honeymoon),
Peter Fonda, Jane's brother, shot himself (and nearly died).
Henry Fonda had two close friends who committed suicide. His son,
Peter, fell in love with the year that she killed
herself, and also had a friend who committed suicide.
Nevertheless, there are limits to what the genogram can show,
particularly regarding multiple marriages. Sometimes, in order to
highlight certain points, the arrangement of the genogram structure
is reorganized. For example, the Fonda family genogram has been
arranged to highlight the ongoing relationship of the with
the Henry Fonda was married five times. His first wife,
Margaret Sullavan, was married four times; Henry was her second
husband. Margaret's third husband, Leland (whowas also
Henry Fonda's agent),was married five times, including twice to the
same wife. Some of his spouses were also married numerous times,
and so on.
indicates other marriages
indicates other marriage and children
Diagram 2.25 Notation for additional information
Some complex family situations may require more than one page
of genograms. It is important that the different genograms are con-
nected in some way. Gerson has developed symbols (Diagram
to connect different genograms displayed on a computer (seeChapter
5). This notation can be used on any genogram to indicate that in-
formation about other and can be found
another genogram.
Genograms are necessarily schematic and cannot detail all the
vicissitudes of a family's history. For example, the Fonda
does not include the following information.
Henry Fonda's first wife, Margaret Sullavan, lived very near the
Fonda family in California with her third husband, Leland
ward, Fonda's agent. After she separated from Leland
she moved with her children to Connecticut, where she lived very
near the
Jane Fonda and Brook Margaret's daughter, reportedly
were best friends growing up and hoped that their parents would
get back together again 1981, p. 132).
Jane's mother's death was apparently kept from her and she only
later found out about it in a movie magazine.
Henry reportedly never discussed his wife's suicide with Peter and
Jane.
Henry Fonda and his mother-in-law held a private funeral for Jane's
mother, which only they attended. Henry went on stage that same
night.
When Peter shot himself in the stomach during his father's third
honeymoon in December 1950, eight months after his mother's
suicide, Henry never asked Peter if he was upset about his mother's
death (which Peter had been told was due to a heart attack).
During Henry Fonda's fourth honeymoon in 1957, Peter got himself
into such a bad state with drugs that his sister sent him to his aunt's
in Nebraska. Henry had to return from his wedding trip to arrange
for psychiatric treatment.
Just after Henry Fonda's fifth honeymoon in 1965, Peter was in-
volved in a drug arrest. His trial ended in a hung jury.
It is clear that Fonda family members have been greatly influ-
enced by suicides and remarriages and that the and Fonda
families were closely intertwined. Perhaps the extraordinary strength
and force of personality that Peter and particularly Jane have shown
in their careers reflect the many traumas they managed to over-
come in their childhood. A comparable force was shown by Eleanor
Roosevelt in response to many childhood traumas, as will be dis-
cussed later. Given the toxicity to families of suicide, the most
traumatic of all deaths, the relevant facts surrounding the suicides
would be critical to an understanding of the Fonda family. Such
ditional family information that does not fit on a genogram should
be attached to it and noted by an asterisk.
1835- 1830-
Q Q
Jakob Sally Rebecca Amalia
Kanner
m.32 m 55
Philip Rosa Marie Paula Alexander
--
-
,
Mathilde Martin Oliver Ernest Sophie Anna Judith Lucy Edward Martha
\
\ ,
- -
Diagram 2.26 Freud family -intertwined
Other problems arise where there are multiple intermarriages in
the family, cousins or stepsiblings marrying, or where children
have shifted residences many times to foster homes or various rela-
tives or friends. There comes a point when the clinician must resort
to multiple pages or special notes on the genogram to clarify these
complexities.
a genogram may be confusing because of the multi-
ple connections between family members, as, for example, in the Sig-
mund Freud family (Diagram 2.26). Both Sigmund and his sister
Anna married siblings in the Bernays family, and the third living
Bernays sibling, Minna, was part of the Freud household from 1896
on. Marital lines are necessarily crossed in this genogram. In addi-
tion, the relationship lines show the conflicts and alliances that
reflect the merger of these two families. For an example of an even
more intertwined family, see the Jefferson family in Chapter 3 (p. 68).
Genograms may become complex when children have been adopted
or raised in a number of different households as in Diagram 2.27,
where the genogram shows as much of the information on the tran-
sitions and relationships as possible. In such cases let practicality
and possibility be your guides. Sometimes the only feasible way to
clarify where children were raised is to take chronological notes on
each child.
-1958 lived
ALC
with oldest
i
1946-48
-1966
jail 1971-74 then disappeared
,'75, '83
4th foster home
\
.
foster home age 2-4
with aunt 1966-69 2nd foster home 6-10
then together in foster home 1969-73 3rd foster home age
and 2nd foster home 1973-82
4th foster home age
then with maternal aunt
Diagram 2.27 Family with children living in other households and foster homes
Finally, there may be a problem with discrepant information. For
example, what happens if three different family members give dif-
ferent dates for a death or descriptions of family relation-
ships? The best rule of thumb is to note important discrepancies
whenever possible. In Diagram 2.28, has given a
of the date of the father's death is closer to
mother. Bradt (1980)uses color-coded to distinguish
source of information, although seem
cumbersome to many clinicians.
Pete
Pete Joe
Diagram 2.28 Discrepant information
In sum, large, complex families with multiple marriages, inter-
twined relationships, many transitions and shifts, multiple
perspectives challenge the skill and ingenuity of the clinician trying
the draw a genogram within a finite space. Improvisation and ad-
ditional pages are often needed.
THE GENOGRAM INTERVIEW
Gathering information for the genogram usually occurs in the con-
text of a family interview. Unless family members come in
ly to tell their family history for research purposes, you cannot sim-
ply gather genogram information and ignore the agenda
the interview. Such single-mindedness will not only hinder you
getting pertinent information, but also alienate the family
treatment. Gathering family information and constructing the
gram should be part of the more general task of joining and help-
ing the family.
Wyszukiwarka
Podobne podstrony:
Gemes Freud and Nietzsche on SublimationNo Man s land Gender bias and social constructivism in the diagnosis of borderline personality disorIntroducing the ICCNSSA Standard for Design and Construction of Storm Shelters[architecture ebook] Design And Construction Of Japanese GardensDarrieus Wind Turbine Design, Construction And TestingUnbreakable’s Guide to Shim Construction and UsageRobinson, Spider and Subsequent Construction v1 0(htm)Resin Transfer Molding and Wind Turbine Blade ConstructionVladimir Nabokov and Sigmund Freud, or a Particular ProblemEV (Electric Vehicle) and Hybrid Drive SystemsMadonna Goodnight And Thank YouFound And Downloaded by Amigo2002 09 Creating Virtual Worlds with Pov Ray and the Right Front EndFunctional Origins of Religious Concepts Ontological and Strategic Selection in Evolved MindsFound And Downloaded by AmigoBeyerl P The Symbols And Magick of Tarotwięcej podobnych podstron